|
Use of Isolagen, Cultured Autologenous Fibroblasts for Wrinkle Reduction.
Authors: Mentz H, Ruiz A, Patronella C, Newall G, Mentz G., Clift V.
The first plastic surgeon to present data on Isolagen (the use of a patient’s own fibroblast cells for wrinkle reduction and acne scar improvement. Dr. Mentz was the only US plastic surgeon to host the phase 2 and 3 FDA studies for design and safety), presented at America’s most prestigious plastic surgery society.
Mentz H, Ruiz A, Patronella C, Newall G, Isolagen, Cultured Autologenous Fibroblasts for Wrinkle Reduction. Podium presentation.
Annual Meeting, American Society of Plastic Surgeons, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania October 12, 2004.
Abstract
Backround
Autologous cellular therapy is a process whereby a patient’s own cells are extracted, reproduced and then reintroduced to the patient for specific cosmetic and medical applications.
Objective
Present the preliminary results of the clinical Phase III FDA protocol undertaken with Isolagen Technologies, Inc. with the use of cultured autologous fibroblasts for the correction of facial rhytids and facial scars.
Materials and Methods
The study was conducted at ten (10) sites in the United States. 154 patients enrolled for treatment and a total of 146 patients were evaluated. Of the 154 patients, 107 were treated for facial rhytids (27 received placebo) and 47 were treated for facial scars like acne and traumatic scars (14 received placebo). These patients were 90.5% female and 9.5% male and were a mean age of 46.8 years old. 91.5% were Caucasian, 4.4% Asian, 1.9% Hispanic, and 1.9% Black. The three (3) mm postauricular biopsies were sent to the manufacturer’s lab and fibroblasts were extracted and grown over a six week period. A 1.2 cc vial of fibroblasts was sent in culture broth (20 million cells/ml) to the treating physician for injection into the dermal defect at three intervals over 3 to 6 weeks. Placebo injections were administered in this random double blind study in 25% of cases.
Assessments were planned at 1, 2, 4, 6, 9 and 12 months by physician and patient evaluation on a 7 level photo scale for each area and a visual analog scale.
Results
We present the data for 1, 2, 4 and 6 months. The results for 9 and 12 months are pending. Patients who improved 2 or more levels on the 7 level photo scale were considered responders. The average placebo response was subtracted from responders in order to underscore the response results. The injected fibroblasts improved facial rhytids and scars, and the results improved with time. At 1 month 57% responded more than 2 levels, at 2 months 79.6%, at 4 months 77.1% and at 6 months 81.6% (Fisher Exact Test <.0001 at 2, 4, and 6 months). There were no serious adverse effects. Other events that did occur included bruising and /or swelling at the injected site.
Conclusion
We feel very optimistic with the initial results. Cultured fibroblast therapy appears to be both safe and effective. The 9 and 12 month evaluations will be completed shortly and we hope to be able to recommend this modality for soft tissue regeneration. Additional research is being conducted to further investigate this modality. The application of this therapy to other soft tissue defects including periodontal disease, stretch marks, and nerve trauma is also being studied.
Slide Presentation (outline)
Use of Cultured Fibroblasts for Facial Rejuvenation
American Society of Plastic Surgeons
Mentz H, Ruiz A, Patronella C, Newall G, Mentz G., Clift V.
Background
Autologous cellular therapy is a process whereby a patient’s own cells are extracted, cultured, and expanded exponentially for reintroduction to the patient for the treatment of specific cosmetic and medical applications.
Objective
Present the preliminary results of the clinical Phase III FDA protocol undertaken with Isolagen Technologies, Inc. with the use of cultured autologous fibroblasts for the correction of facial rhytids and facial scars.
Materials and Methods
154 patients enrolled and 146 were treated with cultured fibroblasts for soft tissue defects.
Defects included: Facial rhytids and facial scars like acne and traumatic scars.
3 mm punch biopsy preceded the fibroblast extraction, culture, and amplification.
Fibroblasts were injected into treatment area at three intervals.
Fibroblasts in Culture
Patient Profile
90.5% were female
9.5% were male
Mean age of 46.8 years old
Ethnic Groups
91.5% Caucasian
4.4% Asian
1.9% Hispanic
1.9% Black.
Study Protocol
1) 25% of patients (41) received a placebo injection.
2) 75% of patients (113 patients) received three injections containing fibroblasts at a concentration of 20 million/ml.
Materials and Methods
1.2 ml of autologous cultured fibroblasts was then returned to physicians office for injection.
A sequence of 3 injections over a 3 to 6 week period was performed.
Injections were done with a 30 gauge needle targeted at infiltrating the dermis.
Results
Results were examined according to photo guide assessment as the objective measure and a scale for overall patient satisfaction.
These findings were recorded by both the patient and physician.
To be categorized as a responder in the study patients had to improve two points or more on a seven point scale.
Isolagen Response Rate
Before & After Glabellar Crease
Before & After Faciotemporal Rhytids
Before & After Nasolabial Fold
Before & After Fine lines at Nasolabial Fold
Before & After Perioral Rhytids
Present the preliminary results of the clinical Phase III FDA protocol undertaken with Isolagen Technologies, Inc. with the use of cultured autologous fibroblasts for the correction of facial rhytids and facial scars. Fibroblasts in CultureMean age of 46.8 years old1.9% Black. 2) 75% of patients (113 patients) received three injections containing fibroblasts at a concentration of 20 million/ml.Injections were done with a 30 gauge needle targeted at infiltrating the dermis.
Adverse Effects
Most commonly occurring adverse effects were injection site edema and pain.
No patients were discontinued due to an adverse effect.
Conclusion
We feel very optimistic with the initial results.
Clinically we observed improvement in fine lines and wrinkles after treatment.
Patients were satisfied with results and the data reveals a statistically significant improvement in the subject’s VAS assessment.
Additional research is currently being conducted in Phase III of the ongoing FDA clinical trial in order to be able to recommend this customized approach of soft tissue regeneration for facial rejuvenation.
References
Boss W, Usal H, Fodor P, et al: Autologous cultured fibroblasts: a protein repair system. Annals of Plastic Surgery 44:5:536-542, 2000.
Boss W, Usal H, Chernoff G, et al: Autologous cultured fibroblasts as cellular therapy in plastic surgery. Clinics in Plastic Surgery 27:4:613-626, 2000.
Watson D, Keller GS, Lacombe V, et al: Autologous fibroblasts for treatment of facial rhytids and dermal depression. Archives of Facial Plastic Surgery 1:165-170, 1999.
|